Templar Health & Safety

Beyond the Fruit Bowl: Why Wellness Perks Are Failing Your Staff

white-screen-res

Shaking Hands in Office

For many organisations, employee wellbeing has become associated with visible initiatives: a bowl of fresh fruit in the kitchen, discounted gym memberships, sit/stand desks, mindfulness apps, and similar perks. These initiatives are often introduced with positive intentions, and many can provide genuine value to staff.

However, workplace wellbeing cannot be reduced to a collection of benefits, incentives, or lifestyle choices. Increasingly, employers are recognising a gap between what they promote as “wellbeing” and what health and safety legislation requires them to manage.

The question for employers should not simply be, “What wellbeing benefits do we offer?” but rather:

“Are we identifying and controlling the workplace factors that could be affecting our employees’ health?”

In the UK, employers have both a legal and moral responsibility to protect the health, safety, and welfare of their employees. Under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, organisations must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health, safety, and welfare of people at work.

This duty extends beyond traditional physical hazards. It includes risks arising from the way work is organised, managed, and experienced by employees, including stress, excessive workloads, workplace culture, poor communication, and the wider working environment.

The uncomfortable truth is that a fruit bowl cannot compensate for a workplace culture that is contributing to stress, burnout, poor morale, or psychological harm.

When Wellbeing Becomes a Benefit Instead of a Duty

Many organisations have developed wellbeing strategies, but some have unintentionally positioned wellbeing as an employee benefit rather than a core health and safety responsibility.

Wellness initiatives often focus on encouraging individuals to make healthier choices—improving diet, increasing physical activity, managing stress, or accessing resources that support mental health. These initiatives can play an important role, but they only address part of the picture.

The risk is that responsibility for wellbeing becomes placed primarily on the individual, while the workplace factors contributing to poor health remain unchanged.

If an employee is regularly working excessive hours, facing unrealistic deadlines, experiencing poor management, dealing with uncertainty, or working in an environment where they do not feel able to raise concerns, a free gym membership or mindfulness subscription is unlikely to address the root cause.

A genuine health and safety approach to wellbeing starts by asking: “What aspects of our workplace could be creating risks to employee health, and what are we doing to control them?”

This is the same approach organisations already apply to physical health and safety. Employers identify hazards, assess risks, introduce controls, and review whether those controls are effective. Psychological health and wellbeing should be managed in the same structured way.

Work-Related Stress: The Risk Many Organisations Are Missing

One of the clearest examples of where organisations can fall short is work-related stress.

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) recognises work-related stress, depression, and anxiety as significant workplace health risks and a major cause of lost working time in the UK.

Stress is not simply about an individual’s ability to cope. While personal circumstances and resilience can play a role, work-related stress is often directly linked to the conditions people experience at work.

The HSE highlights six areas that employers should consider when managing stress risks:

  1. Demands: Issues such as workload, work patterns, and the working environment.
  2. Control: How much say the person has in the way they do their work.
  3. Support: The encouragement, sponsorship, and resources provided by the organisation, line management, and colleagues.
  4. Relationships: Promoting positive working to avoid conflict and dealing with unacceptable behaviour.
  5. Role: Whether people understand their role within the organisation and whether the organisation ensures they do not have conflicting roles.
  6. Change: How organisational change (large or small) is managed and communicated.

Problems can arise where employees face excessive workloads, limited control over how they work, insufficient support from managers, poor workplace relationships, unclear expectations, or poorly managed change.

These issues are not simply matters of employee satisfaction. They can represent genuine health and safety risks that require assessment and appropriate action.

Recognising the Signs of a Wellbeing Compliance Gap

A workplace may have a wellbeing compliance gap where it offers a range of wellbeing initiatives but does not have effective systems for identifying and managing the factors that may be harming employee health.

Warning signs can include:

• Rising sickness absence linked to stress or anxiety

• Increased staff turnover

• Declining engagement levels

• Employees regularly working beyond their contracted hours

• Managers struggling to support teams effectively

Other indicators may be less visible but equally important. Employees may feel unable to raise concerns, workloads may be accepted as permanently unsustainable, or a culture may develop where long hours are viewed as a sign of commitment rather than a potential risk.

These issues should not be treated solely as HR matters. Where workplace conditions are contributing to ill health, they fall squarely within the scope of health and safety management.

Moving Beyond Perks Towards Prevention

A meaningful approach to workplace wellbeing recognises that employee health is shaped by both individual choices and the environment in which people work.

Wellbeing initiatives can be valuable, but they should sit alongside effective leadership, realistic workloads, supportive management practices, and a culture where employees feel safe to speak openly about concerns.

The strongest organisations do not ask only what additional benefits they can provide. They examine how work is designed and managed, whether risks are being identified early, and whether employees have the support and resources they need to work safely and sustainably.

Wellbeing should not be viewed as an additional benefit alongside health and safety. It is a fundamental part of protecting people at work.

Understanding Your Current Position: Undertaking a Wellbeing Audit

For organisations looking to strengthen their approach, the first step is understanding the effectiveness of their current arrangements. A wellbeing and health and safety audit can provide an objective review of how wellbeing risks are currently identified, managed, and monitored.

A comprehensive audit should examine whether psychosocial risks, such as work-related stress and excessive workload pressures, are being recognised within existing health and safety arrangements. It should consider whether policies and procedures reflect organisational responsibilities, whether managers have the knowledge and confidence to support employees, and whether there are effective processes for raising and responding to concerns.

The audit should also explore how employee wellbeing is monitored. This may include reviewing sickness absence trends, staff turnover, engagement feedback, workplace surveys, and any patterns that suggest underlying workplace pressures.

Most importantly, an audit should help organisations move from a reactive approach, responding when employees are already struggling towards a preventative approach focused on identifying risks early and putting effective controls in place.

The outcome should be a clear understanding of current strengths, areas requiring improvement, and practical actions to ensure wellbeing is embedded into the organisation’s health and safety management system.

Because true workplace wellbeing is not measured by the number of perks available. It is measured by whether the workplace itself enables people to remain healthy, safe, and able to perform at their best.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the employer’s legal duty regarding workplace wellbeing?

Under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, employers have a legal duty to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health, safety, and welfare of their employees. This includes managing psychological risks like stress, not just physical hazards.

Why are wellness perks like gym memberships not enough?

While wellness perks are beneficial, they often place the responsibility for wellbeing on the individual and fail to address underlying workplace factors contributing to poor health, such as excessive workloads, poor management, or a toxic culture.

How can an organisation identify a wellbeing compliance gap?

Signs of a compliance gap include rising sickness absence due to stress, high staff turnover, declining engagement, employees consistently working long hours, and a culture where staff feel unable to raise concerns. A wellbeing audit can help identify these issues.

Templar Health & Safety

Your Health and Safety Mentors!

Ready to strengthen your workplace safety? Contact us today to discover how our approach can benefit your business. Fill out the form below, and one of our team will get back to you shortly.

white-screen-res